Town of
Turner, Maine
Planning Board Minutes
May 13, 2009
1
CALL TO ORDER
Called to order at
7:00pm by Mr. Gregg Varney. Mr.
Varney then read the agenda.
Those Members present were Mr. Varney, Mark Morris, Roy
Nickerson, R. Edward Morris, Raymond Lavoie, Margaret Imber and Shirley Twitchell. Planner, John Maloney was
present this evening. CEO,
Roger Williams was also present this evening.
2
ELECTION OF CHAIRMAN AND OFFICERS
Ms. Twitchell
nominated Mr. Gregg Varney as Chairman.
Mr. Nickerson seconded the motion.
The Board Members voted unanimously to elect Mr. Varney as
Chairman. Mr. R Edward
Morris made a motion to elect Ms. Margaret Imber
as Vice Chairman. Ms. Twitchell
seconded the motion. The
Board Members voted unanimously to elect Ms. Imber
as Vice Chairman. Mr. R.
Edward Morris nominated Ms. Shirley Twitchell
as Secretary. Ms. Imber
seconded the motion. The
Board Members voted unanimously to elect Ms. Twitchell
as Secretary.
3
PUBLIC HEARING-RICHARDSON ENTERPRISES
Mr. Varney opened the Public Hearing at
7:02pm.
Mr. Mike Gotto
of Sebago Technics is representing this project this
evening. Mr. Gotto
stated that there is an existing garage located on Route 4. This garage will be used for
the sale of approximately 23 used vehicles.
There will be 12,000 square feet of pavement.
Mr. Varney then asked if there was any input from anyone in
the audience.
Seeing none, Mr. Varney closed the Public
Hearing at 7:05pm.
4
OLD
BUSINESS:
A
TWENTY-MILE OVERLOOK SUBDIVISION
Mr. Maloney stated that the applicant
would like to have this review tabled until the June Planning Board
meeting. Ms. Twitchell
made a motion to table this item until the June Planning Board
meeting. Mr. Lavoie seconded the
motion. The Planning Board Members voted unanimously to table this
item until the June meeting.
B
RICHARDSON
ENTERPRISES-SITE PLAN REVIEW
Mr. Maloney reviewed the Application
Completeness Checklist for Site Plan Review.
Mr. Maloney stated that Item 9 had been provided.
Mr. Gotto then provided the
information for Item 27. Mr.
Maloney then suggested to the Planning Board to waive Items 30, 43,
44, 46, 47 and 50. Mr. Maloney also suggested
waiving the requirement for a statement from a Financial Institution,
the Planning Board Members agreed.
Mr. Maloney then stated that the abutters notices have
been sent and that the spot elevations and soils report have been
completed. Ms. Twitchell made a motion to waive Items 30, 43,
44, 46, 47 and 50. Mr.
Lavoie seconded the motion. The
Board Members voted unanimously to waive Items 30, 43, 44, 46, 47 and
50. Mr. R. Edward Morris asked
about the MDOT permit. It
was stated that there would be 1 curb cut and 1 entrance.
Ms. Twitchell made a motion to accept the
Application Completeness Checklist for Site Plan Review with waivers
30, 43, 44, 46, 47 and 50 as complete.
Mr. Lavoie seconded the motion.
The Board Members voted unanimously to approve the Application
Completeness Checklist for Site Plan Review with above stated
waivers. Mr. Maloney then
reviewed the Finding of Fact and Conclusion of Law with Conditions of
Approval 1 through 8. Ms.
Twitchell made a motion to accept the Finding
of Fact and Conclusion of Law with Conditions 1 through 8.
Mr. Lavoie seconded the motion.
Ms. Imber asked Mr. Williams about
Condition 6. Mr. Williams
stated that when he receives the contract from the applicant is when
the occupancy permit will be issued.
The Board Members then voted unanimously to accept the Finding
of Fact and Conclusion of Law with Conditions 1 through 8.
5
NEW BUSINESS:
A
MATTHEW JORDAN-NON-COMMERCIAL ANIMAL RAISING
Mr. Jordan
stated that he inherited said chickens from his neighbor and now he
is taking care of them. Mr.
Williams stated that this property is located on 4 acres in a
Residential District and a permit is needed to raise Non-Commercial
Animals. Mr. Williams
then read the Conditions associated with Non-Commercial Animal
Raising. Mr. Jordan then stated that
he was not raising these chickens for Commercial Use.
Ms. Twitchell made a motion to allow
a permit from the Planning Board via the CEO, Roger Williams, be
issued with the Conditions assigned by Mr. Williams.
Mr. Lavoie seconded the motion.
The Board Members voted unanimously to approve said permit.
B
DELUCA-HOFFMAN ASSOCIATES-SKETCH PLAN SITE
REVIEW
Ms. Mary E. Gamage,
Director of Real Estate Development and Administration, from
Hannaford Bros. Co. addressed the Planning Board.
Ms. Gamage stated that the proposal is to construct
a 36,000 square foot grocery store on Snell
Hill Road off of Route 4. Ms. Gamage
then referred to the sketch plan map.
Ms. Gamage stated that this project would be built
on 3 parcels of land, which encompasses 8 acres.
Part of this land is in the Androscoggin Land Trust.
The store will have a Drive-Thru Pharmacy and employ
approximately 100 full and part-time employees.
Ms. Gamage then referred to other stores in the
area stating that the store in Auburn
is 47,000 square feet, the store in Lewiston
is 50,000 square feet, the store in Oxford
is 50,000 square feet and that the store in Jay is 25,000 square
feet. The plan is to have a full
application for Planning Board review in July.
Ms. Gamage then stated that the Corporate
Headquarters are located in Scarborough and that there are 167 stores
located in MA, ME, NH, VT and NY.
Ms. Gamage then stated that
Hannaford continues to make healthy choices, has a concern for food
safety as well as offering locally grown produce. In 2008 Hannaford was
honored as one of the 10 healthiest stores in the USA. Hannaford has a strong
environmental focus with 63% in store waste recycled, 75%
construction waste recycled and uses 40% less energy.
Hannaford takes a role in the community very seriously.
Hannaford looks forward to making a donation to the community
on a yearly basis. Ms. Gamage
then stated that this land is zoned commercial and that the building
will be set on the back of the property with 180 parking spaces. There will be limited access
from Route 4 with full access from Snell
Hill Road.
The well will be located on the land owned by the Androscoggin
Land Trust. There will also be public
walking paths installed in exchange for the positioning of the well
on the Land Trust property. Mr.
Doug Boyce, Senior Site Engineering Project Manager, from Hannaford
Bros. Co then addressed the Planning Board.
Mr. Boyce referred to the sketch plan and stated that the
objective was for the best use of the land.
Mr. Boyce stated that the wetlands have been mapped by Stantec
Associates and that Stantec Associates have met with the DEP,
IF&W and Army Corps of Engineers.
This development will impact the wetlands and the bird
habitat. The process for
any permits has begun. A
preliminary meeting with the MDOT has already occurred. There will be a traffic
study. There will be a scoping
meeting held with the Town of Turner. This scoping meeting will
allow the town to tell the MDOT their concerns and the MDOT will tell
the applicant what areas need to be addressed.
Part of the traffic study entails counting cars.
This procedure has already taken place on Snell Hill Road, Route 117
and Route 4. It was again
stated that there would be limited access from Route 4.
Mr. Boyce then referred to a similar store built in Bridgton
located on Route 302, which required a traffic signal.
Mr. Boyce stated if the MDOT found the need to install a
traffic signal that Hannaford would fund such a project.
Mr. Boyce reiterated that the goal is to have a full
application for presentation to the Planning Board for the July
Planning Board meeting. Mr. Varney then asked if
there has been any research regarding the aquifer that appears to be
located under the site. The answer was yes this is
being evaluated. It was
then stated that the well would provide for 2,500 gallons per day.
It was stated that Hannaford is a public water supply. There was a discussion
regarding wastewater disposal system.
It was then stated that the building water storage tank would
hold a 1-day supply of water and that 45,000 gallons would be held
below ground for fire sprinklers. There was then a discussion
regarding the DEP requirements concerning a wet pond and storm water
ponds. The discussion turned to the
delivery trucks. Mr.
Boyce stated that the trucks would enter off of Snell
Hill Road at the rear of the store, the
Hannaford trucks are 53-foot trailers and there could be 1 to 2
deliveries per day, there will also be smaller delivery trucks such
as snacks, beverages, etc. The loading dock will be approximately 4
feet. The Pharmacy
Service window will have an eyebrow canopy.
There will be no connection to Jordan
Lane. Mr. Varney then reiterated
his concern for the aquifer. Mr.
Boyce stated that a study would be done regarding this aquifer.
Mr. Varney then asked about sketches of the proposed building. It was stated that the
sketches would be submitted with the application.
Mr. R. Edward Morris made a comment that the MDOT did not want
to see any additional traffic lights from Auburn
to Farmington.
It was stated that the issue of a traffic signal would be
determined by the MDOT. Mr.
Maloney then asked why was this project kept so secretive? Mr. Maloney stated that this
project was brought before the State, before bringing it to the
community. Mr. Maloney also stated that
the Town of Turner is very
concerned regarding the potential traffic issues on Route 4 and again
asked why no building sketch was presented this evening.
Ms. Gamage stated that the
confidentiality of this project is very complex and that all due
diligence has and is being done.
Hannaford likes to make sure a proposed project will work
before announcing it to the public. Ms. Gamage
stated that the sketch plan of the building unfortunately is not yet
ready. Mr. Boyce then stated that
Hannaford wants to be sure that everything will work.
Ms. Imber then asked about the walking trails and
how they would work. Mr.
Jonathan P. LaBonte, Executive Director for the
Androscoggin Land Trust, stated that these trails would be developed
in exchange for the placement of the well on the property owned by
the Land Trust. These trails would be for
non-motorized use and would encompass a picnic site.
This is a separate project.
Ms. Imber then asked about trash removal at the
Hannaford site. It was
stated that Hannaford uses a hydraulic compactor and takes care of
their trash removal. Ms. Imber
then asked about the storm water being piped through the wetlands
back to the river. It was
stated that, yes, this will take place.
Mr. R. Edward Morris asked about the possibility of snowmobile
trails. Mr. Labonte
stated that he would entertain a separate discussion with Mr. Morris. Mr. Labonte
then stated that he has concerns about folks crossing Route 4 to
access the walking trails. Citizen,
Ms. Jackie Long asked if Snell
Hill Road would be enlarged.
Mr. Boyce answered, yes and explained the improvements.
Citizen, Mr. Mark Rabon asked what are the next steps taken by the town. Mr. Maloney stated the
following:
1.
A detailed Sketch Plan would need to be submitted.
2.
A Site Walk needs to take place.
3.
An application needs to be submitted.
4.
Abutters need to be notified and Public Notice needs to
be posted.
5.
A Public Hearing needs to be scheduled and held.
6.
Technical Reviews need to take place.
7.
The project must meet Town Standards.
8.
One or several meeting will take place for project
review.
9.
A second Public Hearing would take place if needed.
Citizen, Ms. Karen Wilcox asked if the
towns people would have any notification of the MDOT scoping
meeting. Selectmen, Dennis Richardson
stated that this meeting would be a public meeting, held during a
Selectmens meeting. Ms. Imber
then stated that she had concerns regarding the traffic on Main Street. Ms. Long
then asked what time of the day would trucks be delivering. Mr. Boyce stated that there
could be some deliveries in the middle of the night, however the
trucks have no back-up alarms and there is a foam rubber device
around the dock, which helps to elevate noise.
There was then a discussion regarding outside buffering and
truck idling as well as regulation for the maximum decibel level and
headlights. It was
decided that a Site Walk would be held on Wednesday, May 27, 2009 at
6:00pm. Mr. Boyce stated
that the building site would be pinned as well as the storm water
area. The Planning Board would
also like to see the proposed entrance from Route 4 and the 3
proposed curb cuts. Mr. Varney stated that all
of the neighbors are welcome to attend.
Ms. Twitchell stated that she had a concern that
the store is not big and boxy and to please make sure that it looks
nice. Mr. R. Edward Morris then
thanked the Hannaford representatives for their presentation and
stated that he hoped it works.
Recess taken from 8:37pm
until 8:42pm.
6
OTHER
BUSINESS:
None.
7
CEO
REPORT
No action required.
However there was a discussion regarding the detention pond at
Wilson Bluff. Mr.
Williams stated that it appears there is some seepage through the
bottom, which may have been caused by blasting, but it is hard to
tell. Mr. Williams also
stated that it appears there are no erosion issues. Mr. Varney then asked Mr.
Williams about the business use across Route 4 from the Chickadee
Restaurant. Mr. Williams stated that
this is a commercial zone and one use can change to another use.
Ms. Imber then asked about the
business being run by Mr. Guptil on Route
219. Mr. Williams stated that he
has had numerous discussions with Mr. Guptil
regarding the appearance of this business.
Mr. Williams also stated that it is up to the Selectmen on the
pulling of this permit.
8
REVIEW
OF THE MINUTES FROM APRIL 8, 2009
Mr. Nickerson made a motion to accept the
Minutes from the April 8, 2009 Planning Board meeting.
Mr. Lavoie seconded the motion.
The Board Members voted 5 in favor and 2 abstentions to accept
the April 8, 2009 Planning Board Minutes.
Ms. Twitchell and Ms. Imber
abstained from voting because they were not present at the April 8,
2009 meeting.
9
REVIEW OF PLANNER ESCROW
No Action Required.
10
OTHER ITEMS NOT ON THE AGENDA
None.
11
ADJOURNMENT
Motion made by Ms. Twitchell
for adjournment, unanimously accepted.
The meeting adjourned at 8:49pm.
Respectfully submitted by
Karen Wilcox