BOARD OF SELECTMEN MEETING MINUTES

 

MONDAY OCTOBER 15, 2007 7:00 PM

 

1. CALL TO ORDER AND PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG: Chairman Lawrence House called the meeting to order at 7:00 pm and the pledged of allegiance was said. Those present were Mr. Angelo Terreri, Mrs. Jody Goodwin, Mr. Kurt Youland, Mrs. Joan Bryant-Deschenes, Town Manager Eva Leavitt, Representative Ernie Deluca from FPL and Bill Campbell. Also present were several residents with interest.

 

2. ADJUSTMENTS TO THE AGENDA: Town Manager Eva Leavitt requested an item be added to the Managers' business regarding the appointment of an election warden for the November 6th election, which the Board agreed to add.

 

3. REPRESENTATIVE FROM FPL - DISCUSSION CENTER BRIDGE ROAD BOAT LAUNCH: Mrs. Leavitt introduced Mr. DeLuca and Mr. Campbell to relay information regarding proposed improvements to the Center Bridge Boat Launch area. Mrs. Leavitt also noted that Mr. Campbell was the recreation manager for FPL when resident Paul Varney who is now deceased first addressed the Boat Launch area. Mr. DeLuca began the discussion be referencing plans for several of FPL's land areas involving Turner, Leeds, Greene and Lewiston. Then Mr. Campbell from E-Pro Consulting noted that MDOT will be replacing the bridge on Center Bridge Road and will provide some carry-in access off the new bridge. It was noted that MDOT would also provide a sanitation system on a seasonal basis approximately May through October. Mr. Campbell noted that when the boat launch was developed in the late 1980's it was a bear bones project, which will possibly have some updates. Mr. Campbell stressed the importance of local involvement regarding the up-keep, potential vandalism and sanitation.

 

The plans to date may include a courtesy dock, additional parking spaces, some new picnic tables, and, Mr. Campbell offered a cost estimate based on his home town area of approximately $1,500 annually. This fee he explained covers the costs to maintain the area, taking the docks out in the fall and putting them in in the spring. Mr. Campbell noted additional plans for areas further down stream and noted concern that the local fire department maintains their present policy of requiring a permit for campfires. Mrs. Goodwin noted that the free camping allowed on the islands doesn't appear to be taken advantage of by kids out there having parties, and Mr. Campbell noted there were problems years ago, but nothing in recent years. Mr. Campbell noted that, in the event of expense incurred due to weather in excess of $1500, FPL would step in and cover those expenses.

 

Mr. Youland questioned whether or not Leeds and Greene were interested in the proposal, and Mr. Campbell noted that both Leeds and Greene have been contacted, and Leeds is not interested at this time, there has been no official response from Greene. Mr. Campbell noted that the Androscoggin Land Trust has also been contacted to see if there is any interest from them. Mrs. Leavitt noted that she had inquired through MDOT what costs they incur for their rest areas and, it was said to be approximately $6,000 annually; and that Turner could anticipate approximately ½ of that amount. Mr. Campbell re-stated his previous statement regarding the cost to Nobelboro of $1,500 annually, stating that he is a former Selectman for that community and does read the annual report to stay in touch with those costs. Mrs. Leavitt then questioned where the docks would be stored during the winter months; and it was explained that the docks are simply taken out of the water and no storage would be necessary.

 

Mrs. Leavitt then referred to a request submitted by Chairman of the Planning Board, Jeff Timberlake requested that the Board consider having a combined meeting of the Board of Selectmen, the Planning Board and the Budget Committee before making any kind of commitment to the project.

 

Discussion that followed included a request for a time frame that may be attached to the request, which was noted by Mr. Campbell to be November 28th, however, Mr. Campbell noted that this deadline is for FPL to provide an outline of their plan, which will include having contacted the Town of Turner. Mr. Deluca noted that there is no lease or contract to sign, FPL works on a 6-year plan, which can be terminated at any time. Mrs. Goodwin questioned whether or not the Town could pick and choose which, if any amenities that Turner may wish to include, should support from the Town be granted; and, Mr. Campbell assured those present that, yes the Town was free to include any amenities offered. Mrs. Bryant-Deschenes suggested that the next Tri-Town Selectmen's meeting might be a good time to talk to Leeds and Greene regarding this project, as it was noted that there are many residents from both of the other communities that utilize the Center Bridge Road boat launch.

 

There was some discussion to compare portable toilets vs. other types of sanitation systems, which would involve a holding tank. Mrs. Goodwin noted also that perhaps the Bass Masters would make a contribution to the boat launch area as they conduct at least 2 tournaments each year and would greatly appreciate facilities on the premises. Mr. Campbell assured the Board that a decision wasn't necessary immediately, however, he did request a letter from the Town to acknowledge that consideration is being given to the project, and that budget items would also be discussed. The Board of Selectmen will invite the Planning Board and the Budget Committee to their November 19th meeting to discuss the proposal. No further action at this time.

 

4. NEW ENGLAND FORESTRY - PROPOSAL TOWN WOOD LOT: Mrs. Leavitt informed the Board that, as requested, she contacted several foresters regarding a proposal to manage the Town's wood lot, and, only one company, New England Forestry Consultants, Inc. replied. Mrs. Leavitt noted that this lot was last harvested in 1994, and noted, " it's important to cultivate this asset". It was also noted that there isn't any truly valuable "oak" on this property at this time, however, if managed properly the town could see some valuable timber in the future. Mr. Youland inquired how many acres were involved which was stated to be 108 acres.

 

An overall review of the proposal as submitted raised several questions from the Board regarding what aspects are included for which price as outlined in the proposal. Mr. Youland noted that the Town could hire someone to survey the lot and properly mark the boundaries, and, that there are several qualified loggers locally who could do the actual harvesting. Mr. Youland also noted that he felt 15% of the timer harvested is too much to pay and followed that with a motion to offer 10% of the timber sales, no second was made to his motion; and the motion failed. Following some additional discussion, Mrs. Goodwin made a motion to invite a representative from New England Forestry Consultants, Inc to meet with the Board to answer questions; and Mr. Youland made a second to the motion; and the vote was unanimous. Mrs. Leavitt will invite someone to explain the proposal as submitted.

 

5. L/A POLLUTION CONTROL FACILITY CONTRACT - DISCUSSION: Mrs. Leavitt noted to the Board that the contract before them is an event that occurs every five years; and, she noted that the Town of Leeds has not signed one of these contracts in many years and have not been refused by the facility. The facility provides place for local vendors who handle septic waste a place to dump.

 

Discussion that followed clarified the fee of $250 to be an annual fee for the next five years, which reflects an increase of $50/year since the last contract.

 

Mrs. Leavitt clarified that this is a budgeted item, and additional discussion resulted in a motion by Mr. Youland to accept the contract for $250/year for the next five years. Mr. Terreri made a second to the motion; and the vote was unanimous

 

6. TOWN MANAGERS' BUSINESS: Q & A WEEKLY MEMO: Mrs. Goodwin commented on how nice the BQMC building is looking with the recent repair/stain work, and she questioned the work on the roof and why there are rust stains. Mr. Terreri noted that the rust stains are from the old roof. It was also noted that Mr. Bill Dickie who did the repairs/stain work also painted the foundation which had not been part of the original bid; and he will use some of the left over stain to touch up the sign near the road. Mrs. Leavitt noted to the Board that local electrical Dick Thibodeau has done some of the electrical repairs necessary and, also Mr. Warren Palmer has done some other maintenance repairs as outline in the action plan for the Maine Municipal Association, the Town's insurance carrier. MUNICIPAL VALUATION RETURN: Mrs. Leavitt noted this document is one required as a follow up to the Tax Commitment, and Ms. Philipon added that this document is a detailed breakdown of the tax commitment. It was noted no approval is required, only signatures. FINANCIALS: Mrs. Leavitt noted for the Board that the errors discovered in the revenue and expense statements have been corrected. Mr. Youland questioned the extra staff members he has noticed with the Highway Department, and Mrs. Leavitt noted that she is utilizing part-time temporary funds for these positions to assist with the town office project. Mrs. Leavitt noted that no Department is in jeopardy of being overdrawn at this time. The paving & construction projects for this year have not yet been completed, and Mrs. Leavitt noted that the Lower Street project should be completed soon. Mr. Youland advised her to make certain the project gets done on a warm day and that the asphalt is hot, as time is growing short for paving.

 

 

Mrs. Bryant-Deschenes inquired about the telephone poles on Merrills Mills Road and when they may be removed noting that all wiring has been removed from them. Mrs. Leavitt noted that the highway department was waiting for confirmation from Central Main Power for their removal; and noted the process would be complete before snow flies. Mrs. Goodwin questioned what the town might use old poles for and it was noted they are used to identify parking at the Town Beach Lot, among other things. TOWN BEACH: Mrs. Leavitt noted to the Board that she was contacted by Scout Spencer St Pierre who expressed an interest in constructing some horseshoe pits at the Town Beach in the pine grove area as part of any Eagle Scout project. Mr. St Pierre would also build a small tool shed to house the rakes and other tools used during the summer months. No action needed. ELECTION WARDEN: Mrs. Leavitt requested that the Selectmen appoint Mrs. Joyce Moulin to the duties of Election Warden for the November 6th Election and, Mr. Terreri made a motion to appoint Joyce Moulin as Election Warden; and Mrs. Goodwin made a second to the motion; and the vote was unanimous.

 

Mrs. Leavitt then inquired if the Board would discuss action taken at an earlier meeting regarding the transfer of funds from TCA to the Leavitt Institute Building Committee. Chairman House noted that the vote as taken by the Board of Selectmen to transfer money from TCA to the Leavitt Institute Building fund was done in error according to the legal opinion received from the Maine Municipal Association. Mr. House continued by noting that it would be appropriate for someone who voted in favor of the transfer to make a motion to rescind the prior action. Mr. Youland noted that he was the one to make the motion to transfer the funds and asked if the vote was rescinded, then what happens? Mrs. Leavitt explained that TCA would hold a meeting in October to discuss the issue then, as a Board vote to transfer the funds.

 

Mr. House noted that by voting to rescind the previous action taken; the new action will set the record straight, and Mrs. Goodwin noted that the action as taken by the Board of Selectmen to transfer funds from TCA to the Institute Building was an illegal act and, this action would correct that. Mrs. Bryant-Deschenes indicated she was under the impression according to the Town's attorney that the first time money was transferred it was something the Board of Selectmen had authority to do. However, Mrs. Bryant-Deschenes also noted that the bottom line is that both the TCA and the Leavitt Institute Board are advisory Boards only.

 

Mr. Terreri noted at this time that he has never seen or had the opportunity to read the guidelines for a proprietary fund, and further discussion involved an acknowledgement from Mrs. Goodwin that the legal opinion obtained concluded that when the first action was taken by the Board of Selectmen to transfer money, TCA did not have a formal Board and the only way to transfer money at that time was by a vote of the Board of Selectmen. Now that TCA has an established board, money can only be transferred by a vote of that board. Mr. Youland expressed a need for more information, which Mrs. Leavitt then inquired what type of information he was looking for. Mrs. Deschenes noted that the Board of Selectmen had done a transfer in the past, which again was acknowledged by both Mrs. Leavitt and Mrs. Goodwin; and it was noted that the prior action was done when there was no Board of Directors or by-laws. Mr. Youland then questioned how the Board of Selectmen could agree on behalf of the Institute Board of Directors to take less money?

 

Mrs. Leavitt then noted one thing to consider is the inexperience of a new town board, and she noted also that at this place in time there are not a lot of unsettled feelings, just an attempt to make things right and correct. Mrs. Goodwin then noted again that the legal opinion obtained from Maine Municipal Association indicated that the Board of Selectmen had no authority to transfer funds, and that the town records should be corrected. Mr. Terreri noted that it was difficult to obtain the money from TCA the first time. There was then some discussion regarding obtaining yet another legal opinion from the Town's Attorney before taking any further action, and Mrs. Leavitt questioned whether or not a need exists to expend additional money in legal fees. Mr. Youland responded that he felt there was no need to spend any more time on this issue.

 

Mr. Terreri then questioned if TCA was simply going to authorize the funds to be transferred, then what's the issue? It was noted that action from the Board of Selectmen would be an acknowledgement of a mistake and correct it on paper. Mrs. Goodwin also noted that the Town records now reflect an illegal action taken by the Board of Selectmen, and, without a reverse action, the permanent records will remain a reflection of the action as taken. Mr. Youland noted that he wasn't convinced that the action taken by the Board was incorrect. There was then discussion regarding the legal opinion received by Mrs. Bryant-Deschenes which she indicated was shared with the members of the Board. Mrs. Leavitt noted that she did share an e-mail of the opinion from MMA that was sent to Mrs. Bryant-Deschenes. Mrs. Bernice Gilbert, member of the Leavitt Institute Committee questioned if the money as agreed to be paid by TCA to the Leavitt Institute could be done on a monthly basis? Mrs. Leavitt indicated that she was of the opinion the money would be disbursed quarterly and Mrs. Gilbert asked if the money could be done monthly instead, which Mrs. Leavitt will inquire about at the TCA next meeting. Following this discussion Mr. Youland noted that it was his opinion that this matter should be left the way it is until and if it is challenged. Mr. Youland then made a motion to move to the next issue and Mr. Terreri made a second to the motion; and the vote was four in favor, Mr. House, Mr. Terreri, Mr. Youland and Mrs. Bryant-Deschenes, one opposed, Mrs. Goodwin.

 

7 CONSIDERATION OF ANY OLD BUSINESS: VACANCIES TCA/BUDGET COMMITTEE/ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS: Mrs. Leavitt noted that no one has stepped forward to fill the vacancies on TCA, however, two people have expressed an interest in the Budget Committee, Mrs. Mary Briggs and Mr. Ralph Caldwell; and Mr. Winston Gilbert Jr has applied for consideration on the Zoning Board of Appeals. Mr. House explained that at their previous meeting the Board was tied for consideration of the vacancy now on the Budget Committee and, as a result of that he polled the remaining members of the Budget Committee and was able to reach seven of the existing members and five of those seven expressed a desire to have a woman appointed to the committee.

 

 

 

Mrs. Bryant-Deschenes expressed her disappointment that a vote was taken at the previous meeting and Selectman Kurt Youland stated that he previously worked with Mr. Caldwell on the Budget Committee for thirteen years and noted Mr. Caldwell knows the budget process very well and can bring a level of experience to that committee that Mrs. Briggs can't. Following this he then made a motion to appoint Mr. Caldwell to the Budget Committee, and Mr. Terreri made a second to the motion; and the vote was 3 in favor, Terreri, Youland, Bryant-Deschenes and two opposed, House, Goodwin and the motion passed. Mr. Terreri then made a motion to appoint Mr. Winston Gilbert Jr to the Zoning Board of Appeals and Mr. Youland made a second to the motion; and the vote was unanimous.

 

Following this Mr. Youland questioned if the Board members might consider moving the meeting time ahead during the winter months from 7:00 to 6:00 pm. Mrs. Goodwin indicated that 6:30 would work better if the time was to change, and Mrs. Leavitt informed the Board that if the meeting time were to change a public notice would need to be placed in the local paper. Following some limited discussion Mr. Youland then made a motion to leave the meeting time at 7:00 pm and Mr. Terreri made a second to the motion; and the vote was unanimous.

 

8. CONSENT AGENDA: Mr. Youland reviewed the disbursement warrants, and with one correction recommended their approval. There were two requested amendments to the minutes from October 1, 2007, which will be made. Mrs. Bryant-Deschenes will review for 11/5/2007. There were no Veteran's Exemptions and no abatements or supplements to consider. Mr. Terreri then made a motion to approve the consent agenda with amendments and Mrs. Goodwin made a second to the motion; and the vote was unanimous.

 

9. EXECUTIVE SESSION: None needed

 

10. ADJOURNMENT: Mr. Youland made a motion to adjourn at 9:07 pm and Mrs. Goodwin made a second to the motion; and the vote was unanimous.

 

Respectfully submitted:

 

Sandra L Philipon

 

Assessing/Office Assistant